Audience: Young Adult
A ten-point buck and a dead body make the same sound when they hit the forest floor.
– opening sentence
This story revolves around the mystery of what happened at River Point when five friends went hunting and one was killed. Afterward, the “River Point Boys” decide to stick together and say that none of them knows who fired the shot that killed their friend. Kate is interning at the DA’s office and she is determined to get justice for Grant. But it isn’t clear who killed Grant and without evidence, the DA could succumb to the pressure from the powerful families of the boys to sweep the incident under the rug.
The story is well-written and seems realistic, except for the fact that Kate is the only one who can find evidence to solve the crime. Adults aren’t always as inept as YA novels make them out to be. But, I get it – Kate is the intrepid sleuth (ala Nancy Drew).
The plot was slow at times, but I always wanted to keep listening to try to figure out who the killer was. Most of the book is told from Kate’s point of view with periodic sections from the POV of the killer (without giving away who it is). I enjoyed hearing what the killer was thinking and planning. I had a hard time keeping the names of the boys straight but that may have been a factor of listening to the audiobook. There are two narrators and they both did a great job. The plot twists, including one that reminds us how technology can hide the truth, make up for the slow parts of the book.
Overall, I enjoyed the book and would recommend it to YA mystery fans.